
work by eva hesse
The unrest and struggles that arose from national crisis in the United States in the 1960’s allowed artists some form of “aesthetic liberation” and to take up a voice about the “nature and limits of art itself.” This freedom provoked new thinking in the discourse on art and some of the developing movements. Eva Hesse, a prominent German-born American sculptor, was active in the New York art scene at a pivotal time for both women and sculptors. In and era dominated by the simplicity of form stressed in Minimalism, Hesse managed to maintain a minimalist style, while questioning the idioms of the movement and instilling a personal and painterly quality, reminiscent of abstract expressionism, in her works. Contingent, in particular, depicts the culmination of her explorations into the boundaries between painting and sculpture, contradictions and her view of beauty and the absurd.
Born into a Jewish family is concentration camp Germany in 1936, her childhood was riddled with trauma. After her families escape to New York, her parents divorced and her mothers fell into severe depression, which led to her eventual suicide. Hesse’s dark and expressive sensibility in her work that derived from her past was contrasted with her romantic belief in “the redemptive quality of art,” which gave her work a humanistic quality uncharacteristic of other minimalist works. After graduating with her Masters from Yale University in 1959, she met Tom Doyle a “more mature and developed artist” whom she married in 19619 and together they moved to Ruhr, in West Germany, to, in 1964. Hesse had been struggling for years with her art, plagued by the “atmosphere defined by the Holocaust” that she felt upon her return to her native Germany. Her attempt to find her artistic and creative niche were convoluted by the questions that “women were beginning to ask” about their identity as the feminist movement began to emerge. She “fought to achieve recognition at a time when the art world acknowledge few women”, and when sculpture, in particular, was seen as a male form of expression.
It wasn’t until Doyle suggested that she experiment with materials lying around the factory where they lived, that she found a love for string and chord. She started a series of relief works where she literally translated the lines from her drawings onto masonite panels. Shortly after their return to New York, Hesse and Doyle’s marriage collapsed and Hesse was freed from her husbands shadow.
With the relief works as a starting point in sculpture, Hesse discovered “her mature vocabulary” and toyed with different materials and Minimalist formal devices such as repetition. Her works “carried an air or mirth and jokiness and an unmistakable whiff of eroticism”, which allowed her pieces a feeling of humanism not typical of Minimalism, since, according to Jeanne Siegel, she never “fleshed out the exactitude” required for the movement. Hesse was also influenced by Anti-form, a movement announced in a 1968 article in Artforum by Robert Morris, known for informal installations18 and “random pilling” and “loose stacking” which rejected and criticized the form of minimalism.
Painting, the medium in which she was originally trained, always remained the strongest influence in her work. Her sculptures remained very frontal and often were “dependent on the wall,” whether it was hanging on the wall such as Metronomic Irregularity 111 which is a mounted sculpture or in Accretion which consists of 50 fiberglass and polyester resin tubes leaning against a wall. Expanded Expansion is dependent on the wall in such a way that it is a screen-like, wall structure. She also remained very concerned with the surface of her works, playing with texture and luminosity, constructing things in layers, sometimes binding and wrapping in an obsessive, often labor intensive manner. Ultimately, however, it was the “intrinsic qualities” of the material that “conveyed meaning”. She experimented and explored, letting the material take its form, similar to the painting process of abstract expressionism. Her works showed the process of things being transformed so that “painting and sculpture can no longer be neatly distinguished.” Her experimentation led to the feeling that her works create “tension between geometric and organic forms” and explore contradictions and opposites, enjoying the absurd that arises from the juxtapositions she creates.
In April of 1969, Eva Hesse collapsed and was rushed to hospital. 28 It was discovered that she had a brain tumor. Over the following year, she underwent three unsuccessful operations and became increasingly ill. Contingent, one of her last five pieces, embodies her view on art, beauty, material and process. In an interview with Cindy Nemser in 1970 Hesse explains how she “ started the piece before I got sick, which was last year.” The piece was on the cover, in full color, of Artforum in May of 1970, the same month that Eva Hesse died. The work consists of eight banner-like strips of cheesecloth, covered on the top and bottom with reinforced fiberglass, and latex in the middle section. The latex is pulled taut between the weight of the end pieces as all the pieces hang in a row, spaced apart, perpendicular the wall. It was completed by friends, as Hesse was too ill to complete it herself, and she supervised from her bed.
Contingent brings to mind layers of skin, or bandages, with both the texture and colour. In this way, the piece maintains a feeling of being organic, which contrasts the formal and minimalist elements of the work. Something seems haunting, yet familiar – as if each hanging cloth holds a similar tension and presence as a human body.
The particular choice of materials also speaks to the presence that this work holds. Latex has a shelf life of about six months before it starts to deteriorate, change colour, and eventually become fragile and brittle. According to her Catalog Raisonne “she was very aware that it was temporary….She would say that it was an attribute. Everything was for the process – a moment in time, not meant to last.” This creates a contrast in the work – the tension between the extreme durability of the fiberglass next to the ephemeral and temporary use of latex. She knew that life was not permanent, and did not feel that art should be either. “Absurdity” she felt, was “the key word. It has to do with contradictions and oppositions”.
Artist Jackie Winsor “felt that there was a quality in the color and texture of the surface” that seemed to carry an “emotional pitch that was very poetic and haunting” and created more of an ambience. It speaks to an “extremely personal” reach of experience that is “beyond or beneath speech,” and its authority is derived from its originality. Hesse’s concern seems to be with the “condition of the edge” – she is not focused on the boundaries within a type of work, but rather with the edges and lines that separate painting from drawing, allowing this work to be neither and both. The work feels both beautiful and repulsive, a border she enjoyed to tempt while playing with space and intrusive abilities of edges. She had hoped to “get to non-art, non connotative, non anthromorphic, non geometric, non, nothing” and wondered “how to achieve by not achieving? How to make by not making?.”
While Hesse never touched on topics of revolution or politics of the world that surrounded her in her work, nor did her experience with the Holocaust, nor her relationships with the men in her life ever seep into her pieces. Issues of gender roles can rarely be seen, nor are any blatant opinions or messages made clear. What comes across, rather, is her belief in the absolute absurdity of life, which she expresses in her joy of playing with extreme opposites and contradictions. She was able to change the view of women in art, sculpture, and shifted the perception of Minimalism.
“No one can see the exhibition in the same way as it would have been seen in 1968”. Not only does the piece appear different as it ages, with discolorations and a complete change in the experience of the work, but also what it represents no longer exists. It “showed that repetition, the grid, scale” all formal aspects of this piece as well as formal aspects of Minimalism, thought to be a cold, logical and mathematic take on art “did in fact have evocative powers that echoed our experience of the world and our bodies”. By allowing her experiences, her childhood, her rocky marriage, the anxiety that plagued her, and finally, her diagnoses, seep into her work, she added a personal, emotional element to a style or art that was never meant to have one. Minimalist sculptor, Carl Andre wrote that “perhaps I am thee bones of the body of sculpture and perhaps Richard Serra is the muscle, but Eva Hesse is the brain and nervous system extending far into the future”.
Serota, N. Eva Hesse: Sculpture. London: Raithby, Lawrence & Company Ltd. 1979
Britt, D. Modern Art: Impressionism to Post Modernism. London: Thames & Hudson. 1989.
Britt, D. Modern Art: Impressionism to Post Modernism. London: Thames & Hudson. 1989.
De Zegher, C. Eva Hesse Drawing. London: Yale University Press. 2006.